BREAKING: Hong Kong gov’t given chance to take fight against same-sex couples’ housing, inheritance rights to top court
Hong Kong Free Press
The Hong Kong government has been given the chance to take its appeals over housing rights for same-sex couples who married overseas to the city’s top court.
The Court of Appeal handed down its decisions for two cases relating to access to public housing and inheritance on Monday. The government had sought to have the cases heard at the city’s top court, the Court of Final Appeal.
Both decisions came after lower courts in 2020 and 2021 ruled in favour of same-sex couples who got married overseas, granting them equal access to the city’s public housing under two schemes and to the same inheritance rights as heterosexual couples. Over the years, the government has sought to challenge those verdicts.
Last October, the Court of Appeal shot down both of the government’s challenges. For the public housing rights case, the court ruled that existing measures of the Public Rental Housing Scheme and Home Ownership Scheme breached the Basic Law’s provision that all Hong Kong residents shall be equal before the law.
For the inheritance laws case, the court said the differential treatment amounted to discrimination against same-sex couples.
Justice of Appeal Thomas Au wrote in the written judgement: “[The prosecution’s] arguments in essence amount to saying that there are certain core rights and obligations that are attached and unique to traditional opposite-sex marriage to give it a special status.”
Years-long court battles
The decisions on Monday marked the latest step in years-long court battles for LGBTQ rights advocates, with the earliest case lodged as far back as 2018.
That year, Nick Infinger – who got married to his partner in Canada – filed a case against the Housing Authority challenging the Housing Authority’s refusal to consider his application for public housing because his same-sex union was not recognised.
In 2019, Edgar Ng, who married his partner Henry Li and purchased a flat under the government’s Home Ownership Scheme – lodged a judicial review to challenge the Housing Authority.
The challenge came after the authority said it excluded same-sex spouses of homeowners from the definition of “family members” and “spouses,” meaning Li was not allowed to co-own the flat with Ng unless he paid a premium.
Also in 2019, Ng filed a judicial review against the Secretary for Justice to challenge the fact that marriage provisions did not include those who entered same-sex marriages overseas. Ng was concerned that because of the lack of recognition, his Home Ownership Scheme flat would not be transferred to Li in the event of his death.
Ng passed away in December 2020, after which Li took over the cases.
Judicial reviews are considered by the Court of First Instance and examine the decision-making processes of administrative bodies. Issues under review must be shown to affect the wider public interest.
Activists have often criticised Hong Kong’s limited rights and protection for the LGBTQ community, seeing the judicial system as the only hope for reversing laws they say are rooted in discrimination.
In September, the city’s top court handed down a partial victory to LGBTQ advocate Jimmy Sham, ruling that the government has an obligation to provide an alternative legal framework that recognises same-sex relationships. The ruling, however, stopped short of granting full marriage rights to same-sex couples in the city.
The government was given two years to develop a mechanism that recognises same-sex relationships before the court could say the government was in breach of the law.
Support HKFP | Policies & Ethics | Error/typo? | Contact Us | Newsletter | Transparency & Annual Report | Apps
Help safeguard press freedom & keep HKFP free for all readers by supporting our team
HKFP has an impartial stance, transparent funding, and balanced coverage guided by an Ethics Code and Corrections Policy.
Support press freedom & help us surpass 1,000 monthly Patrons: 100% independent, governed by an ethics code & not-for-profit.